The Lady in Red

In my January post ‘The Lady in Blue’ I wrote about why, in Christian art, the Virgin Mary is traditionally clothed in blue.

However, one of my favourite paintings of all time has the Virgin – scandalously – clothed in red.  And it is painted by one of the most scandalous characters in the history of Western art.  The glorious, the rebellious, the irrepressible, the one and only, Caravaggio!


Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571-1610) is the quintessential Baroque painter. Baroque art and architecture were the Catholic Church’s visual weapons in the war to beat back the Protestant Reformation and, as such, a masterclass in theatre, drama and spiritual transcendence. Which is why it is so gloriously ironic that the greatest proponent of this artistic counteroffensive was a man who lived a wholly irreligious and notorious life – constantly in fights, having to go on the run for committing murder, nearly murdered himself and then dying ignominiously on an Italian beach while on his way back to Rome to ask for a pardon from the Pope.

Caravaggio trailblazed a painting style called Tenebrism. Tenebrism uses extreme light and shadow to sculpt the scene, creating a highly theatrical and dramatic effect as if we were viewing a scene on a stage rather than in a painting. Many of Caravaggio’s works have an equally theatrical, and often red, curtain in the composition – here the trademark drape takes up over a third of the painting.

800px-Death_of_the_Virgin-Caravaggio_(1607) - Copy

But what makes this painting so scandalous is not its theatricality, but its reality. To impart the message of the artwork to the illiterate faithful, Christian artists would endow the saints with attributes so that they could be easily identified. For instance, St Lucy is typically portrayed carrying a platter bearing a pair of eyes as her own eyes were gouged out in the process of her martyrdom. But here Caravaggio employs no attributes and hence we cannot know for certain who each attending figure is.

800px-Death_of_the_Virgin-Caravaggio_(1606) - Copy

But even worse than this is the portrayal of the Virgin herself.


Not only is she in red, but she is in an everyday dress with the fastening slightly undone, with her hair awry, and her feet filthy and bare!  She truly looks dead. (Portrayals of this scene in Christian art are rare and often symbolic rather than real.)  And just to add to Caravaggio’s already infamous reputation, the rumour went round that the figure of the Virgin in the painting was modelled on that of a murdered prostitute who had been dragged, bloated, from the Tiber.


The only saintly reference is the delicate golden halo above the Virgin’s head.

But what a unique, touching and emotive portrayal of grief Caravaggio has achieved.  Scandals aside, the painting remains a sublime depiction of the scene.

That’s Caravaggio for you.  A painter who was as scandalous in his painting as he was in his life and yet produced works of exquisite spirituality.  

And I love him!

Do you have a favourite painting?  And is it scandalous?



  1. Do you think he painted her in red to be deliberately provocative, or was he using the red to make her stand out? It’s a gorgeous painting – I love the quiet banality of it, showing the normality of death. If we’re thinking scandalous then I nominate Courbet’s The Origin of the World. I saw a very detailed exhibition of his work in Montpellier some years back of his work and this painting – which I knew – still caught people’s breath as they passed, some unable to stop and look. I think it’s a fantastic work. Certainly in your face!


  2. The question of the red is a tricky one. The fact that the model is thought to be a prostitute just adds fuel to the fire! I will be looking at this in my next post.
    Yes, The Origin of the World still has the power to shock. And I think the title really adds to it. If it was titled Female Nude or some such the shock would be modified. I don’t know why it shocks us really because it is the origin of the world. I think it is also to do with the fact that the rest of the body is covered. Good choice!


Let me know your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.